Slam Debunk

A friend of mine, Shawn G., sent me the link to an article by J. B. Handley (https://jbhandleyblog.com/home/lockdownlunacy) which meticulously and strongly suggests, if not proves, that most policies used to handle Covid-19 were unnecessary.

It is an article which stands out in that it is very well researched and heavily cited. Yes, it is long, and there are some typos in it. (Please, everyone should have someone proofread their work; otherwise, you look sloppy and possibly Ted Kaczynski-like. But I digress.) I am not going to summarize all the excellent points and evidence contained therein as there are so many that I would basically end up rewriting the article.

I will emphasize a couple of passages, though. Here is one relating to the Imperial College models of the disease’s course through the population of the U.S.:

It’s safe to say that the reason the United States locked down, and the reason the White House extended their lockdowns was almost exclusively due to the models created by Imperial College Professor Neil Ferguson . . . . Oddly, Professor Ferguson has a history of massive overestimation of pandemics, but apparently no one bothered to consider that in taking his advice.

Based on all the evidence presented in the article, J. B. Handley concludes:

When you digest all of the facts we now know about COVID-19, the simplest policy recommendation actually makes the most sense in my opinion: If you have COVID-19, stay home. If you must go out, wear a mask. Everyone else, wash your hands, and get on with your life. It should have been that easy, but instead we chose to lockdown society, an unprecedented step.

I hasten to add, though, that high risk individuals still need to protect themselves as they see fit.

As for the future, the author quotes Dr. D.A. Henderson, “the man who led the public effort to eradicate smallpox,” and his colleagues:

“The negative consequences of large-scale quarantine are so extreme (forced confinement of sick people with the well; complete restriction of movement of large populations; difficulty in getting critical supplies, medicines, and food to people inside the quarantine zone) that this mitigation measure should be eliminated from serious consideration.”

There is also an excellent section about Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and how his state took care of the vulnerable population of nursing home residents instead of investing in a long-term lockdown. Who would’ve thought I would ever find living in Florida so desirable?

Please read the article. Anyone who is still in favor of lockdown after reading the whole thing, let me know. I am genuinely curious why.

A Letter to Non-Earthlings

Dear Aliens:

I will start with an apology right away, because I don’t know your cultures, so I’ll probably commit a typical Earthling faux pas without being aware of it.

If you have been on our planet only a short while, you might think all we care about is the coronavirus: Yes, there are daily updates on numbers of people infected (and dead) in the United States and the world, discussions on the science of contagion, details about what governments are doing to “slow the spread” or “flatten the curve,” tales of children who are stuck at home, accounts of lonely people desperate for a hug, special coronavirus sections on major websites (even one on the Google Maps app), a tragicomic headline about someone crashing a car due to hypoxia while wearing a mask, and a news item about a physician who committed suicide, etc.

But, please believe me: It is a story about the surface of things. It is much easier to talk about fighting a virus than to look at more thorny problems. You may have also noticed, for example, that here in the United States, 45% of citizens are obese. So many people still smoke, even knowing the health risks. Lots of people have heart trouble. Stress is high. There are tons of lonely people, and opioid addiction is everywhere.

I know our earth websites and newspapers are comparatively silent about these things that can’t be fought as invaders, and officials are not issuing any sweeping edicts regarding them. From your perspective it probably looks like earthlings prefer to avoid looking deeper into the causes of their unhappiness. And no, it doesn’t make any sense that our nation’s strategy of isolating everyone is probably actually increasing addiction, abuse, and deep loneliness. It also probably looks like we are basically a species given to panicking and overreacting. Luckily, not all of us are that way. One woman wrote:

I don’t think any amount of fear is healthy. Unless you’re talking about the fact that if you have fear about a street, you’ll look up and down before crossing the street. . . .  But I don’t think that’s fear. That’s just being sensible. (Peace Pilgrim, Her Life and Work in Her Own Words, page 68)

I hope you’ve been on Earth long enough to know what a street is. It is a dangerous place where we drive terrestrially based vehicles that often kill some of us. Also, regarding some things above, smoking is taking the products of combustion into the lungs which increases the chance of cancer. Cancer is a nasty and painful disease. Obesity is caused by eating way more than one needs, and suicide is taking one’s own life. You might need a dictionary for a lot of what I’m writing about. But then again, you have apparently solved the issue of traveling faster than the speed of light, so I’m sure you can figure it out. Although I bet the smoking, obesity, and suicide are still puzzling.

Anyway, to follow that Peace Pilgrim quote: To slow down coronavirus spread and possibly save some of our at risk people, we have enacted some precautions that could be construed as sensible, such as wearing masks to prevent exhaling, coughing, or sneezing the virus into widely shared indoor spaces. Others, such as closing parks and wearing masks outside, where people are not coughing or sneezing on each other, well, okay, they don’t make much sense. Overall, I’m sure you’ve noticed that because of fear, one now has to prove that an activity will not lead to infection instead of having to prove that something does lead to infection. You might wonder if we are on our way to ever increasing and time-consuming measures. We might be.

This leads to my big question of you, my dear aliens: Could you please help us out here? Because we are a species that only sometimes seems able to take care of ourselves. We don’t solve big problems like widespread starvation. And if there is a virus, we focus all our attention on it.

I understand that maybe Earthlings are a bit scary to you the way we are always talking about waging a war against genetic invaders. After all, you yourselves are invaders with different genetics, I assume. So I wouldn’t go showing yourselves openly. That would be a bad idea, given our history of burning witches and the Spanish Inquisition and things like that.

I know it may not seem sometimes like we are worth helping, especially if you think about the witches, the Inquisition, the Holocaust, and people who deny the Holocaust ever happened. But again, I think we are worth saving; there have been some people who were cool. Such as, again, Peace Pilgrim, who also wrote this:

Your mind, also your body and your emotions, can only be adequately controlled by the divine nature, not the self-centered nature. If you really love people, you do not fear them. If you live in harmony with divine will, fear is gone. If you identify with that within you which is immortal, you do not fear death. If you fear, it is because your life is still governed by the self-centered nature. (Id., page 161)

You know what, come to think of it, maybe she was an alien. Maybe you’ve been sending aliens all along trying to help us out here. In that case, thank you. And also, if it’s totally going to shit down here, please take all people away on your ships and let the Earth go on without us. Maybe you have special classes somewhere on how not to suck as a species.

Finally, as one of our great wise men, Dieter, who I now realize was probably also an alien, said, “This story has become tiresome. Now is the time on Sprockets when we dance.” Please give me some alien dance lessons, too. That would be cool.

Hopefully,

Another Frigging Earthling
 

Acknowledgments: Thank you to Charles Eisenstein and Jeff Foster for inspiration. And Shawn G. for introducing me to their work.

Dear Mr. Reaper

Grim Reaper
22 Apocalypse Way
Stygian Acres, Hades 00000

 

Dear Mr. Reaper,

Thank you for submitting your renewal form for your 2020 Soul Harvesting License. As you are no doubt aware, the COVID-19 outbreak is causing elevated terror levels amongst middle-class white people. This has somewhat complicated the 2020 soul harvesting season, and there have been several rule updates, which are outlined below:

—The following changes to the 2020 soul harvesting rules are effective IMMEDIATELY—

1) The souls of people hiding* from coronavirus, or any pathogen that may be reasonably mistaken for coronavirus, are NOT to be harvested. This includes souls in voluntary OR involuntary quarantine, jail, prison (including death row), nursing homes, hospitals, and hospice care. (see section 4 for exemptions)

* “Hiding” is defined as the act of fear-driven isolation (e.g. cowering, skulking, trembling) characterized by:

-the consistent maintenance of a 6-foot distance from other souls

-the repetition of at least 1 obsessive/compulsive behavior (e.g. handwashing, paper hoarding, application of antiseptics to foodstuffs)

-the posting/re-tweeting of at least 3 COVID-related articles or slogans per week

2) The souls of people who accidentally come into contact with coronavirus while shopping for groceries, medications, alcohol, firearms, or other essentials, as well as those of people who come into contact with coronavirus while visiting a doctor’s office, hospital, post office, or any other approved essential place of business, are NOT to be harvested, PROVIDED they maintain the condition of “hiding” as defined above. (See section 4 for exemptions)

3) The souls of workers at any approved “essential” businesses are NOT to be harvested, PROVIDED they maintain the condition of “hiding” as defined above. (See section 4 for exemptions)

4) EXEMPTIONS: The following souls are exempted from rules 1-3 and MAY be harvested:

-the souls of people who receive a false positive test and become ill or depressed as a result of isolation, fear, or exacerbation of pre-existing illness

-the souls of people who receive a false negative test and succumb to COVID (up to the accepted limit of 30% of the total negative test results)

-the souls of people who become ill due to non-COVID ailments and are unable to get medical help

-the souls of people with chronic conditions who due to COVID panic are receiving improper or insufficient medical care

-the souls of any people NOT infected with coronavirus AND/OR failing to meet the proper definition of “hiding” as defined above, including, but not limited to, victims of: heart disease, cancer, stroke, pneumonia, flu, Alzheimer’s, kidney failure, diabetes, suicide, starvation, malnutrition, drowning, electrocution, car accident, boat accident, plane accident, alcoholism, drug overdose, Parkinson’s, aneurism, poisoning, gunshot, stab wounds, tuberculosis, malaria, measles, preterm birth complications, land mines, bombs, air pollution, water pollution, soil pollution, domestic violence, non-domestic violence, radiation poisoning, earthquakes, volcanoes, hurricanes, typhoons, tornadoes, wildfires, house fires, snakebite, spider bite, jellyfish sting, tiger attack, bear attack, hippopotamus attack, crocodile attack, shark attack, tightrope walking, extreme sports, non-extreme sports, extreme video gaming, careless selfie-taking, sadness, depression, broken heart, angst, Weltschmerz, and ennui

We feel these temporary rule changes will help drastically reduce middle-class white anxiety, while only minimally affecting this year’s soul harvest. Your understanding and cooperation is greatly appreciated.

Sincerely,

Humanity

The Law of Conservation of Energy

The total energy of
An isolated system
Remains constant.
Energy, like matter,
Is neither created
Nor destroyed.

I know this.
Which is why I went
Quite confusedly
Through my isolated system
Searching for the energy.
Any I could find.

Oh, I did find some…

Seeping meekly from
A trio of mismatched bulbs
In a dusty, bug-filled fixture…

Buzzing in brief, menacing bursts
From the wings of a paper wasp
Seeking refuge from the rain…

Falling in the incessant sleet
Of fingertips on keyboard and screen…

These were remnants
(Or so I thought)
Left behind after some
Unseen exodus of energy
From one end of my
Isolated system
To another.

Energy has a sound,
A smell, a feeling.
It should have left a clue
When it relocated.
A thunderclap
A whiff of ozone
A flash of heat
As the energy retreated
Into the attic, perhaps.
Or the toolshed.

The absence of energy
In an isolated system
Has its own sound.
A pitchless, timeless drone.
Audible inertia.
And it smells like apathy
Sprouting in old dishwater.
Feeling? That’s a tough one.
That requires a bit more energy
Than I can find right now.

I’m beginning to suspect
That the energy took one look
At this isolated system,
Gave William Rankine the finger,
And destroyed itself.

Open letter to Sundari Mase, M.D., Sonoma County Health Officer

Doctor Mase:

First of all, I want to acknowledge how hard it must be to decide what measures to take to protect those at risk of dying from COVID-19. Secondly, I believe that you are taking what you believe to be the best measures.

With that in mind, there are many questions I have that I believe others share:

Is there evidence of someone being infected by SARS-Co-V-2 while outdoors? And if that evidence exists, how high is the risk? Is there evidence that people at the beaches on the weekend of March 21 and 22, 2020 were not maintaining social distance? Some of those who were there say that people were in fact doing so. What rationale exists for closing all parks in your March 23 Order? Why were steps not taken to enforce social distancing first before the shutdown?

As of April 29, 2020 at 8:30 p.m., in Sonoma County there have been a total of 232 known cases of coronavirus infection with 25 hospitalizations and two deaths. Also, I have personally heard case after case of people being turned away from testing because their symptoms were too mild, and although that is merely anecdotal evidence, it does beg the question: Where is the evidence that our County is not already nearing herd immunity? The low numbers of confirmed cases seem very unexpected: In our County (as opposed to a densely populated area like New York City with lots of indoor spaces where people congregate) is this virus less easily spread? Is it less virulent than previously thought?

Slowing the spread and containing the virus is one way of looking at the situation, one story. There are other lenses to look through, such as considering individual immune function. One question I have had all along is why are so many people in the high risk categories? Does the Sonoma County Health Officer have plans to study individual immunity and recommendations regarding that?

Another lens is to consider the other needs of the population. While we are learning about the coronavirus, we are simultaneously taking part in an experiment in widespread social isolation. How is the Health Officer planning to address the emotional, mental, and physical stress brought about by this experiment? Having the Warm Line for people under emotional stress and anxiety is a small beginning.

The negative emotional and mental effects of the Health Officer’s orders as well as the lack of lucid explanation for the orders leaves me wondering what the plan is for our County. No clear rationale has been presented for the measures of sheltering in place and closing the parks while the length of time of these Orders is open for further extension. Specifically, were other strategies considered, and why were these rejected? Would the strategy have been different if California had not dismantled its pandemic preparation in 2008 and onward?

Further, given the slow and steady increase of confirmed cases and lack of widespread testing, how will we know when it is safe to lift the sheltering in place? Are we waiting for the approximately 50% immunity that conveys herd immunity? How will we know when that has arrived? What exactly is the plan? Once sheltering in place is lifted, when will those at high risk be safe to leave their houses? Without information, citizens are left guessing. While I understand that all of us are learning as we go, why has the Health Officer not explained to the citizens of Sonoma County clearly what her plan is?

Lastly, I believe that the Health Officer needs the trust of her population, and she needs to also trust her population. A good way to begin to build mutual trust would be to open up all parks while maintaining social distancing protocols within them if necessary. (I do appreciate the recent slight amendment of the parks closure to allow those who live close enough to bike or walk.) A second way would be to explain decisions she has made. Instead of saying something has been enacted to “slow the spread” of coronavirus or “to save lives,” please clearly show why those decisions are necessary. Please consider other possible plans and why those have been rejected, and take into account the needs of the population as a whole.

Sincerely,

Joseph P. Young
Santa Rosa

Acknowledgments: All those mentioned in my other article “We’re All Gonna Die!” as well as Rose Conner, Gail Hartman, Tanna Jordan, Michael McCarthy, and Nick for talking about this issue, which is not saying they agree with me at all. An extra thank you to Cliff Bernzweig and Thomas Young again for discussing things in great detail.

Time

What time is it?
Looks like…half past nine.
Is there something I’m supposed to do?
What exactly was it that
I used to do right now
Back when “now” had meaning?
If I remember it, eventually,
I’ll do it later.
Maybe.

What day is it?
Well, it’s Thursday here
But it’s still Wednesday where you are
And I’m talking to you
On Zoom…or Skype?
No, it’s Zoom.
So what you say on Wednesday
Actually reaches me a day later.
That’s quite a delay, man!
They should really fix that.

What week is this?
Is this the one where we were
Supposed to be in France?
Or is it the one where we were going
To that party at your brother’s house?
I can’t even recall
What the occasion was.
Or is.
Or will be.
If it ever will.
Or was.

What month is it?
How many goddamn weeks
Have we been hiding in
This bloody foxhole?
When are we going over the top?
I really want to meet the enemy
Face to face, Captain.
Before our supplies run out.
Or they sever our communications.
Or we just forget what time is
And we forget what time was
And we lose what will be
And what could have been
And then…what was this fight
Even for?

Dear Earth,

I know this is supposed to be your “special day” and all, and we should be, like, singing songs to you or whatever, but we just had to tell you we know what you did, and it’s NOT COOL. Not cool at all. Did you think we wouldn’t know it was you? I mean it was either you, or Climate, or Evolution, or Natural Selection, or one of your other little minions who did it, but come on, it was your idea. This virus shit? That’s pretty low, even for you. Look at us. We are all hiding from you and your fucking trickster girlfriends because of your little stunt. We might have to get a restraining order against your ass. Or a “cease and desist.”

Why would you do this to us? After all we’ve done for you? Remember that time we got a bunch of 20-year-olds to plant random trees all over the place? Wasn’t that nice? Or the time we made our cars a little bit less dirty? Or when we kinda sorta stopped killing all the elephants and rhinos for a little bit? Those were good times, baby, you know they were. Look, we know we haven’t been perfect, but we’ve changed a LOT. We even made this special day for you just to show you how much we’ve changed. Just to show you how much each and every one of us loves you and takes you seriously. But this virus thing – it’s almost like you don’t even want us around. Pretty fucking cold. That’s colder than your polar ice caps, and I’m talking about how they were back before they started melting. ICE COLD.

You are better than this, baby. Please, just stop. Stop embarrassing yourself, with your little pandemic stunt. Just take a deep breath, and think about the good times, and we promise you will feel better. Hey, we’ll plant even more random trees. And get some more celebrities to stop using palm oil. Maybe we can even get one of them to write you a really nice song, and you can forget about this silly pandemic idea forever. Ok? Does that sound good to you, baby?

You need to admit what you did to us, and we will forgive you. But we can’t go on this way. We are running out of Netflix shows, and we are sick of using those shitty recycled paper towels that don’t absorb anything. So knock it off, or we really will have to get that restraining order, baby, and we know you don’t want that.

Love,

Humankind